In this lesson plan, students consider the ethical questions surrounding violence in virtual reality. By reading about the 1990s debate regarding the power of video games to produce violence in the real world, they discover that these are old questions that take on new urgency in the age of virtual reality.
Students engage with an intellectual debate that played out in popular discourse. They articulate an opinion based on the information. By experiencing virtual reality (VR), students discern the difference between video games and VR. They then produce a VR game trailer with iMovie by piecing together scenes/ content from films and shows that engage with artificial intelligence and VR.
Two class sessions.
Students should have access to iMovie. If there is no access to iMovie, ask students to write an essay about the ethical issues related to VR.
Video editing with iMovie.
Access and Adaptability
This lesson plan has three components.
1) Two excerpts about the 1990s debate regarding violent video games. I recommend a) Violence, Inequality, and Human Freedom, by Peter Iadicola, Anson Shupe, 58-60, b) “The Rise and Fall of Video Gaming’s Most Vocal Enemy” by Julian Benson.
This is also a helpful timeline.
2) Students engage with VR technology. This can be eliminated and substituted by demonstrations of VR technology through YouTube.
3) Students create a 1 minute trailer for their own VR video game through iMovie. If classroom computers do not have iMovie, then ask students to come up with an idea for a VR game together in a group.
1) Students describe the reading assignments and adopt a position based on the information. May violent video games cause real violence? Students then muse about the difference between VR and current video games. Would VR complicate their opinion on the relationship between fantasy and reality?
2) Students then experiment with VR technology, preferably a violent game like Resident Evil. If the instructor does not have access to VR, please skip this.
1) Show students two video clips that exemplify the possible future, and ethical problems, with VR and AI. I recommend these two clips:
The Matrix: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cqxwtEdxOCw
West World: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eX3u0IlBBO4
2) Students then learn to use iMovie and create a short 1 minute clip of a VR game. Students will submit their trailers for review. Instructors who do not have access to iMovie may ask students, placed in groups, to produce an idea for a VR game. They should be able to describe exactly what instinct or desire the idea exploits for commercial value.
In-Class or Assignment Instructions
The DWRL has produced a very helpful list regarding the technological options available to instructors interested in video/ audio production. It may be found here.
Instructors should assess the engagement of students with the reading material, visual clips, VR technology, and iMovie. Because they are participating in interactive programs, like VR and iMovie, instructors may assess the students’ understanding of the material each step of the way.
Then they may write another short essay as a follow-up, describing whether or not virtual reality complicates their original position on the possible ethical problems.
Finally, the iMovie represents the third assignment, in which instructors may assess the various components of the iMovie: a cogent engagement with violence, the development of a coherent trailer/ narrative through video editing, and creativity.